John Smyth report on Bishop of Salisbury described as ‘horror movie’, church faces reckoning

John Smyth report on Bishop of Salisbury described as 'horror movie', church faces reckoning

The Church of England finds itself at a critical juncture following the release of the John Smyth report, a document that has sent shockwaves through the religious community. The Right Reverend Stephen Lake, Bishop of Salisbury, has likened the report to a “horror movie,” emphasizing the devastating impact of the abuse perpetrated by John Smyth on young boys at Christian camps.

A harrowing revelation : the john smyth report

The Makin Review, as the report is officially known, has exposed a dark chapter in the Church’s history. Bishop Lake’s stark comparison to a horror film underscores the gravity of the findings. He stated, “The trouble is it’s not fiction, it’s real, and very real every day for victims and survivors.”

The report’s contents have led to significant repercussions within the Church hierarchy. Most notably, Justin Welby resigned as Archbishop of Canterbury, facing mounting pressure over his failure to report Smyth’s abusive behavior. This unprecedented resignation marks a turning point for the Church of England, forcing it to confront its past failures in safeguarding vulnerable individuals.

The impact of the report extends far beyond the corridors of power in the Church. It has reopened wounds for many victims and survivors, bringing to light the long-lasting trauma inflicted by Smyth’s actions. The Diocese of Salisbury, which covers a vast area including much of Wiltshire, Dorset, and the Channel Islands, has emphasized the need to focus on victims’ experiences and learn from them.

Safeguarding : a critical priority for the church’s future

In the wake of the report’s release, Bishop Lake has stressed the importance of prioritizing safeguarding measures within the Church. He asserted that whoever takes over from Justin Welby must ensure that safeguarding is “front and centre” of their leadership agenda. This emphasis on protection reflects a growing awareness of the Church’s responsibility to prevent future abuses.

The Diocese of Salisbury has outlined its commitment to implementing robust safeguarding practices. These efforts include :

  • Appointing safeguarding officers in every parish
  • Providing ongoing training for clergy and volunteers
  • Establishing a professional safeguarding team to advise and support
  • Engaging directly with victims and survivors of abuse

Bishop Lake acknowledged the progress made in recent years, stating, “Over the years, safeguarding practice has improved.” However, he also recognized that there is still much work to be done to rebuild trust and ensure the safety of all individuals within the Church community.

John Smyth report on Bishop of Salisbury described as 'horror movie', church faces reckoning

The church’s “jimmy savile moment”

In a particularly poignant statement, Bishop Lake drew parallels between the John Smyth case and other high-profile abuse scandals, referring to it as the Church’s “Jimmy Savile moment” or “Rolf Harris moment.” This comparison highlights the scale and severity of the abuse, as well as the institutional failures that allowed it to continue unchecked for years.

The revelation of Smyth’s actions has forced the Church to confront its past and question its ability to protect the vulnerable. Much like the scandals involving Savile and Harris, the Smyth case has exposed systemic issues within a respected institution, leading to a crisis of faith for many.

It’s worth noting that Salisbury has faced other challenging incidents in recent years, though unrelated to the Church, which have also tested the community’s resilience.

Looking ahead : rebuilding trust and ensuring accountability

As the Church of England grapples with the fallout from the John Smyth report, it faces the monumental task of rebuilding trust and implementing lasting change. The Diocese of Salisbury has emphasized its commitment to these goals, stating that it will “continue to work to implement good safeguarding practices, supported by clergy and volunteers in our parishes and advised by our professional safeguarding team.”

Key areas of focus for the Church moving forward include :

Area Action
Leadership Appointing a new Archbishop with a strong focus on safeguarding
Transparency Open communication about past failures and ongoing improvements
Victim Support Providing resources and assistance to those affected by abuse
Prevention Implementing stringent vetting processes and ongoing monitoring

The Church’s response to this crisis will be closely scrutinized in the coming months and years. Bishop Lake’s candid acknowledgment of the severity of the situation and his call for decisive action represent a crucial first step. However, the true test will lie in the Church’s ability to translate words into meaningful, lasting change.

As the Diocese of Salisbury stated, “We remain committed to engaging with victims and survivors of abuse.” This commitment must be at the heart of all future actions if the Church hopes to regain the trust of its congregation and the wider public. The John Smyth report may have exposed a horrifying chapter in the Church’s history, but it also presents an opportunity for profound and necessary transformation.

Romuald Hart
Scroll to Top